Patient interviews reveal what determines HAE attack severity
Site, duration of swelling, emotional context affect perceptions
Written by |
Researchers asked patients to rate HAE attack severity and the effects on their lives. (Photo by iStock)
The severity of hereditary angioedema (HAE) attacks depends on where swelling occurs, how long symptoms last, and the associated emotional and psychological effects, according to interviews with patients.
The findings suggest that current methods for evaluating the cost-effectiveness of HAE treatments may underestimate their benefits by failing to capture the full impact of attacks on patients’ quality of life.
“Patient-defined severity, shaped by location, phase, and context, challenges simple severity classifications and indicates that severity definitions should also incorporate attack location, symptoms and phase to more accurately evaluate the benefit of new treatments,” the researchers wrote.
The study, “Attack severity in hereditary angioedema: a qualitative study to inform future economic evaluations,” was published in the Journal of Medical Economics.
HAE is marked by recurrent episodes of swelling that can affect any part of the body. Swelling in the mouth, tongue, or throat can be life-threatening because it may block breathing, while abdominal attacks can cause severe pain. Unpredictable attacks can disrupt work, social activities, and daily life.
Measuring cost-effectiveness goes beyond economics
Evaluating the cost-effectiveness of long-term preventive therapies for HAE requires understanding how attacks affect patients’ health-related quality of life. However, economic assessments often classify severity based on factors such as activity limitations, attack duration, or the need for medical care, which may not capture the full patient experience.
The researchers interviewed 25 adults with HAE in the U.S. about how they judged attack severity and its effects on their lives. Most participants were women (76%) and white (80%), and 80% had HAE type 1. They had been diagnosed for an average of 24.7 years, and most (84%) had been prescribed long-term, preventive treatment at some point.
Participants reported an average of 27 attacks in the previous year, most commonly affecting the abdomen (96%), hands and arms (92% each), feet (88%), face (84%), throat (72%), and genitals (68%).
Abdominal attacks were often considered severe because of intense pain and difficulty carrying out everyday activities.
“I would so rather go through labor than go through abdominal attacks,” said one patient, who added that “sometimes you don’t want to live anymore.”
Throat attacks were also rated as severe because of the risk of breathing difficulties, even when other angioedema symptoms were limited.
“I would always call that severe because if I wouldn’t treat it, I would probably … it would stop my breathing,” one participant said.
Facial swelling could cause embarrassment, fear of judgment, and avoidance of social situations or work. Hand and foot attacks varied in severity, depending on whether swelling interfered with work, gripping things, walking, or wearing shoes.
Genital attacks could cause concerns about urination, intimate function, and possible lasting effects.
“You don’t know like if there’s gonna be like permanent damage … could be kinda like scary to think about long term,” one participant said.
Participants also described anxiety about attacks worsening, uncertainty about when to seek treatment, and additional distress when attacks occurred away from home, where medical help might be harder to access.
The impact of an attack extended beyond the period of most severe swelling. During the early (prodromal) phase, uncertainty about whether symptoms would worsen could trigger anxiety. After swelling subsided, fatigue and low energy sometimes made it difficult to resume normal activities.
The early phase generally lasted a few hours to a day, while the main attack could last from less than an hour to several days. Recovery could take hours or about a week, and sometimes longer after severe throat attacks.
The findings indicate that attacks classified as equally severe may affect patients differently. For example, both abdominal pain and hand swelling that prevents someone from working can be disabling, but in different ways. Economic models that overlook differences in attack location, symptoms, emotional effects, and recovery may not fully capture the benefits of preventive treatments.
The findings support a more patient-centered definition of HAE attack severity that considers location, symptoms, duration, emotional impact, and recovery, the study found.
The researchers noted limitations, specifically the small sample size, predominantly female U.S. participants, reliance on recalled experiences, and lack of detailed information on on-demand treatment use and effectiveness.
Future studies should assess quality of life across attack phases and explore economic models that account for symptoms before and after attacks, they said.
Leave a comment
Fill in the required fields to post. Your email address will not be published.